Why I Don’t Make My Child Say “Sorry”

I’ve seen it time and time again, and I’m sure you have too… A child darts past another child, knocking over their block structure, yelling an un-empathetic “Sorry!” over their shoulder as they run off to continue their play. Young children are being taught to say “sorry” long before they are actually developmentally capable of feeling sorry for their actions. The act of saying sorry appeases adults because it’s the polite thing to do, but teaching children to say sorry is not the same as teaching our children to be empathetic towards others, and here’s why:

A child develops the ability to understand that other people have thoughts and feelings different than their own around 4-5 years of age; this is know as “theory of mind.” Prior to that, children’s brains are egocentric; the world revolves around them. During the toddler years, kids need to be taught how to respond in social situations because they don’t yet have the understanding that other people can feel differently than they do.

When we teach our kids to say “sorry” as a blanket response, we are teaching them that all their actions have equal impact. Saying “sorry” implies that the child feels regret for what they have done, which most of the time is not the case (and this is completely normal in typical development). By making kids say sorry, we are also teaching them that they don’t need to do anything more to fix whatever it is that they’ve done.

Obviously, we wouldn’t just ignore our children’s negative actions because they are too young to understand what it means to feel sorry. So what can we do instead?

Teach your child to look for emotional cues in others

If my child has hurt another child, I get down on his eye level and stop the behavior immediately. I point out the impact of his actions by saying something like “Look at her face, she is crying. That really hurt her.” By pointing out the other child’s feelings, my child is learning that his actions have real consequences. This is the beginning of my child’s development of theory of mind – the understanding that others have their own feelings.

Teach your child to respond

Then I have my child “check on” the other child by asking them “Are you ok?” This acknowledges that the other child has been hurt, and it is the first step to making amends. If your child has the language skills, teach them to ask the other child, “How can I help?” or “What can I do to make it better?”

Teach your child to take action to help

Finally, I ask my child to take action to help the person they have offended. This looks different depending on the situation. For example, if my child has broken down another child’s block tower, I would ask them to help fix it. If my child were to bite another child, I would make him go get the other child ice and sit with them. Not only is this teaching my child to be more empathetic to others, but it is also teaching important social skills. If my child walks away from this negative situation feeling like he was able to be helpful, to be a good friend, then he will naturally become more motivated to do the right thing next time.

Model saying sorry

Even though I don’t require my child to say “sorry,” I still model saying sorry when it’s appropriate. In the same way that I model saying “please” and “thank you,” I model saying sorry because it is a social skill that children and adults need to be able to do. Children will naturally pick this up once they are old enough to know what it means to feel true empathy…to feel sorry for something they have done. By this time, they will have developed the prosocial skills needed in order to be helpful, kind and gentle to others.

Interested in positive parenting? Here are some books to get you started!

These are affiliate links. If you click on a link and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. For more information, please read my disclaimer here.

        

18 thoughts on “Why I Don’t Make My Child Say “Sorry”

  1. This is great! I was a little apprehensive with the title but I totally see your point. It’s so important for them to understand the meaning more than the word. I live in Germany, and the kids rarely say they are sorry, but it’s because they don’t teach empathy here or knowing wat it means to hurt someone feelings. It really creates an unfortunate environment and is continued into adulthood. People are very unaware of others and have no regard for if they offended someone. I think America leans more towards the make your kids feel as guilty as possible, which creates people pleasers. I definitely teach my son about empathy and what being sorry actually means, but I don’t shy away from the word so that the person being offended also knows that there is an exchange of empathy, along with action behind it. I guess it’s a balance for me. Making sure my child doesn’t do things just to appease me or the one being offended.

    1. I 100% agree with you. It’s all about knowing your own child and what will help them build true and genuine empathy over time. It also has a lot to do with your background and culture, like you said. Thank you so much for your thoughtful input!!

  2. This makes total sense. I have put a lot of effort into making my toddler say sorry in the past when she obviously doesn’t ‘feel sorry.’ Teaching them empathy is much more important at this point of their life. By the way, I read like 5 of your articles and learned so much! 🙂

  3. So what do you do when the child refuses to help fix the tower or get ice and sit with the other child in your examples?

    1. Great question! Of course, every child is different and each situation varies in severity, but in general this is what I do both in my preschool classroom and with my 2.5 year old son… If they refuse to help fix the tower or get ice then I would say to them “It looks like you aren’t ready, let’s take a break until you are ready to help your friend.” I would sit with them away from the group and let them know that whenever they are ready, they can go and make “amends.” This is not a punitive “time-out,” but instead it is a gentle reminder that the expectation is that they fix the tower, get ice, etc. In my experience, it usually only takes a minute or two for the child to decide on their own that they are ready to do what needs to be done to help the other person.

  4. I agree with you 100%!… to a certain age, but once a child is old enough to understand what being sorry means they should be required to say it. I know far too many people that weren’t required to say sorry, please or thank you and still don’t say it as an adult (even though it may have been modeled by their parents)
    Being polite is becoming a thing of the past, so we must work harder to ensure our kids don’t grow up to be rude adults.

    1. I absolutely agree. Once a child is older and has the understanding then they should be held accountable in that way. It’s all about respecting the child’s development and guiding their behavior along the way… we know that they will continue to need the support and reminders even as they get older. We definitely don’t want our kids to grow up to be rude or entitled!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *